It was a pretty good speech, the one Governor Parson delivered Wednesday. It was the annual State of the State speech. Governors have been giving them since Alexander McNair did the first one on November 4, 1822 at the start of the Second General Assembly of the State Of Missouri. The speech lasted about 17 minutes. Governor Parson’s speech lasted about 42 minutes.
As far as we can determine, his speech was historic because it was the first SOS address that did not take place before a joint legislative session meeting in the House chamber. Even in the St. Charles Capitol, where the House and Senate met in adjoining rooms, the Senate joined the House for McNair’s 1822 speech.
And, as far as we can determine, it was the first time a State of the State Address was not given during a joint session. In fact it wasn’t given during a session of the legislature at all. Neither chamber was in session. Another historical point.
Mark these circumstances down to an external historical event that had become too internal—the COVID-19 pandemic. The House leadership decided Wednesday morning that the House could not be used because of fears the event would turn into a super-spreader of the virus. The situation was so out of hand in the House that it didn’t even meet the previous week.
That near-last hour decision provoked a big scramble that resulted in moving the speech to the Senate where there is far less room for social distancing on the floor or in the galleries. We’ve heard there were concerns the Senate could muster a membership majority for an afternoon joint session.
As a result, neither chamber was in session. The Senate gave permission for the speech to be given there, much as it gives permission for the Silver-Haired legislature and other mock legislatures to use the chamber. Reports indicate about one-third of the Senate membership stayed away.
The House Information Office, which has a pretty sophisticated audio/video system it uses for special events in the House, managed to move all of its gear into the Senate galleries and strung all of its cables, and mounted all of its cameras in a matter of a few hours and produced a high-quality video feed on the governor’s Facebook page (maybe I’ll tell you sometime how close the Missourinet once came to beginning daily video feeds on its webpage many years ago). I watched it. I thought it was flawless.
The galleries of the Senate chamber were uncomfortably crowded with Parson cabinet members, guests who would become show-and-tell examples of certain points the governor wanted to emphasize, other special folks and as many House members as wanted to crowd in.
Normally, the House and the Senate appoint a special escort committee to escort the Governor into the House chamber. But with neither chamber being in session there could be no escort committee—another possible first.
At the appropriate time, the back doors opened and in walked a masked Governor Parson. Alone. No handshakes on the way in, as usually happens. Fist bumps only during the walk down the much-shorter than usual center aisle.
Forty-two minutes (and probably about 6,000 words) later, the governor put has mask back on and he and Teresa walked hand-in-hand back up the aisle and out of the chamber. I’d never before seen a governor and First Lady walk back down the legislative aisle after a State of the State speech. Another touch of history on that day.
There was no State of the State message in the First General Assembly—
—because we weren’t a state then. Congress had given Missouri permission to elect a state legislature and state officers and draft a proposed State Constitution in 1820. McNair gave the first state governor’s inaugural address on September 19, 1820, almost eleven months before Missouri was a state. His three-minute speech was so short that a goodly number of legislators were still in a grog shop down the street in St. Charles and missed it. They wanted him to have a do-over and he refused. Then came the 17-minute SOS in 1822.
As we have researched the history of the Capitol, we have come across a lot of State of the State messages in legislative journals. Some are amazing. For a good part of our history the governor did not deliver the message. He sent the message to the House, often with the Secretary of State or his personal secretary carrying it. Then somebody read it. And read it and read it.
And read it.
Long ago we learned that the average person speaks at about 150 words per minute. It’s a natural pace for most of us. Any faster and the listener is tense, waiting for the next work. Any faster, and clarity of speech might suffer. So, using the 150 wpm standard, here’s how long some previous State of the State speeches have lasted.
On November 22, 1836 (the legislature in those days met after the harvest and quit in time for spring planting, “Lieutenant Governor and Acting Governor” Lilburn Boggs delivered a speech that covered seventeen pages of the House Journal. The word counter on my computer says the speech was 8,873 words long. Whoever read it probably took about an hour to give. It’s hard to imaging many applause breaks since the big buy himself wasn’t reading it. So there was little to keep people awake. Maybe they didn’t suffer as much as we think because in those days church sermons of two or three hours were not uncommon and the listeners were sitting on split log benches without backs.
John Cummins Edwards, the youngest governor in Missouri up to that time, used 6,681 words in 1846, a more modest 45-minute speech, probably.
Sterling Price’s Christmas Day State of the State speech in 1854 was 7,114 words long, would have lasted a couple of minutes longer than Edwards did. His speech took 12 pages of the House Journal. We’re not sure if this was the first time it happened, but after the speech, the House ordered thousands of copies printed, including 2,000 copies in German—as more and more Germans started flowing into Missouri from their country that had been torn by revolutions for several years.
We ran out of energy on the John Marmaduke speech in 1887. It took up 19 pages.
Joseph Folk was a populist who was elected in 1904. He was so full of ideas for cleaning up a corrupt government that his SOS took 14,071 words to express. All those words probably took two hours and 22 minutes to read.
TWO HOURS AND 22 MINUTES!
Forrest Donnell, the governor that majority Democrats tried to keep from taking office in 1941, gave his final SOS on January 3, 1945. He could have spent a lot of time talking about his accomplishments steering our state through most of the World War, but he didn’t. 4180 words, 28-30 minutes.
The first State of the State given by Warren Hearnes in 1965 took 3,063 words.
By the time Donnell and Hearnes spoke, governors were delivering their own remarks. That is likely to be the greatest motivation not to talk endlessly.
The longest SOS we ever covered was Joe Teasdale’s first one. Since the Missourinet broadcast it, we clocked it. An hour and 17 minutes. It seemed interminable. And it was still more than an hour shorter than Folk’s message.
But unlike all of those other State of the State messages, the one given by Governor Parson this week might become a “lost speech.” Why?
Because it wasn’t given to a joint session. In fact it wasn’t given to a session of either chamber of the legislature.
As we write this, we haven’t seen the journal from yesterday, Thursday, yet. But since the speech was given outside of the legislative day, it doesn’t qualify to be in the journal. If that’s how it turns out, the speech will achieve still another historic first—-there won’t be an official record of it in either journal. Perhaps a century from now somebody who has the questionable intelligence to spend hours reading legislative journals will wonder why there was no State of the State message in 2021.
There was one. Pretty good one. Well-delivered. Well-covered by the media. But if it’s not in the journals, it will be Mike Parson’s “lost speech.”
UPDATE: The unapproved journals of the House and Senate for the day of the speech, which are available on the web pages of the chambers, do not include the speech.
Perhaps when the Senate reconvenes any senator, without objection, could ask that the speech be entered into the journal. Or not. Strange times. It will be interesting to see how well the implicit social distance between the speaker and governor serves the Salus Populi.
In the day and age of the internet will a speech ever be lost? If it is on YouTube we can watch and see it “forever”. I enjoy reading your thoughts.