DEI

Donald Trump’s war on diversity, equity, and inclusion hit a huge land mine on election day. The kinds of people he wants to deport, the kind of people he calls names, the kinds of people who are not straight, White Christians, the kinds of people whose traditions and historic lands he disrespects all were acceptable to a broad sample of American voters.

The politics of division, disrespect, diminution, and dismissal have not been stamped out in this election. But they have been reduced.  We as a people might take comfort in what this election says about us but we should not become comfortable, for there is much more yet to be done.

More than one-fourth of the 435 U. S. House members next year will be minorities—61 Blacks, 55 Hispanics and 22 Asian-Americans or Pacific Islanders. For the first time, three members of the Senate will be Black, two of them women including Julianna Sratton, the second African American Senator from Illinois (the first Black woman Senator was Illinois’ Carole Moseley Braun, the first woman of color elected to the Senate, ever, who served 1992-1999 when she became our Ambassador to New Zealand. ).

We have a Black woman governor for the first time in American history—Keisha Lance Bottoms of Georgia, one of five black governors elected this time.   Gina Hinojosa not only is Texas’ first Democratic governor in three decades, she’s the first Latina Texas Governor.  California also has  its first elected Latino governor Xavier Becerra (José Antonio Romualdo Pacheco, in 1875, was the first California Latino governor but he served out the last nine months of the term of Newton Booth’s term after Booth was elected to the U. S. Senate) .  For the first time, there is a Native American governor—Deb Haaland of New Mexico. Maryland has elected its first Black Governor, David Crowley. And in Florida, Byron Donalds—a Republican—is the first black governor in that state’s history.

Delegate Stacey Plaskett, a non-voting member of Congress since 2015, is the first Black woman elected governor of any of our United States territories or jurisdictions. She had been one of the House prosecutors in Trump’s second impeachment. She’ll be returning to her home in the U.S. Virgin Islands to serve.

Senator-elect Chris Pappas from New Hampshire will become the Senate’s first openly gay member. Representative Sarah McBride, the first transgender member of the House, was re-elected by Delaware voters. The first Native American Senator will be Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota. The Senate also will soon have its first Muslim member, Abdul El-Sayad of Michigan, whom Trump disparaged during one of his Me-rallies as a “jihadist.”

The leading candidate to become the new Speaker of the House is African-American Hakeem Jefferies.

And let us not overlook that Trump nemesis Latitia James, the first woman of color to hold statewide office in New York, has been elected to a third term as State Attorney General.

One of Trump’s greatest affronts to the mixed cultural and racial heritage of our country came earlier this year in Dubuque Iowa where he went to make a campaign speech shortly before the election.  Dubuque has this 105-foot long, 28 feet high racial solidary mural on the side of one of its buildings. The tattoos on each of the upraised arms spell “diversity.”

The White House ordered the mural be covered while Trump was there. The city was not consulted.  City leaders would not tolerate Trump’s intolerance and ordered the private management company handling the event to take down a concealing tarp.

We don’t know if Trump saw the mural or what he thought. But at this point, what he thinks is rapidly becoming less important as his days in office trickle away.

He sits as a man reduced in stature and he doesn’t like it.  Diverse, equitable, and inclusive America is prevailing over him and his supporters who have tried to make us fear one another and in our fear hate “others” and limit or exclude them.

Senior Fellow Nicol Turner Lee at the Brookings Institution thinks it is unlikely we’ll see Trump’s policies “resurge” and says, “While the midterms were a referendum vote on Trump’s ailing economic policies and the war in Iran, they also sent a clear reminder that national and global demographics are changing rapidly and that democracy is actually determined by voters, not zealots.”

Trump is America’s King Canute. The 12th Century historian Henry of Huntington wrote of Canute who, unlike Trump, tired of those who enjoyed being close to power, ordered his throne taken to the seaside where he commanded the tide not to come in. He, with his throne, retreated as the water swirled around his legs.

Henry records Canute did it not because he believed he had the power to prevail over natural forces but to prove to his sycophantic disciples that “the power of earthly kings is vain and limited,” as one source has put it.

President Trump, who is incapable of knowing his power is “vain and limited,” is fighting against a tide of time and is unlikely to accept  that the nation has spoken with an engulfing tide that not only was blue, but also was black, brown and rainbow colors.

(Photo Credit: City of Dubuque)

The Party’s Not Over

Things move quickly in the political world. The time for celebrating the resurgence of the Democratic Party and the routing of many Republicans must be short.  Both parties now are in full post-election combat mode.  How much can Trump get done before the majorities change  the Congress? How much can the still-minority Democrats keep from happening?

Let’s leave that alone for a while.

A former student at the long-gone Kemper Military Academy in Boonville once said. “All I know is just what I read in the papers, and that’s an alibi for my ignorance.”  We are going to operate from Will Rogers’ position for a while today.

Texas Senator Ted Cruz called the election results, “a Watergate-level repudiation.”  Florida Governor Ron DeSantis was even more dramatic: “It’s the political equivalent of a meteor strike,” and called it “close to an extinction-level event” for the party. Outgoing House Speaker Mike Johnson said, “I’m sorry that the voters made the wrong choice.”

C’mon guys,—

Take

a

breath.

Voters did not make a mistake although many showed by their choices that they thought they HAD made a mistake by electing Donald Trump two years ago. Cruz was closer in his evaluation than DeSantis was. The Republican Party is not a dinosaur that will die in today’s cold, dark, contaminated political atmosphere and become a fossil to be excavated and studied years from now.

The Republican Party is damaged but is very much alive although it will have to decide if the Trump, Johnson, Cruz, and DeSantis generation is the kind of people who can lead it back. We’ll tell them a secret: It can’t.

The Republicans are reminiscent of the condition of the Democrats two years ago. The party cannot rely on those who dug this hole to dig it out. Whether they like it or not, they need to look at the Democrats where a new order has developed since the Biden days and has seized the public’s attention for this recent election.

The old order that revolves around Trump might remain in power for now, but within two years new voices will emerge—as they have done for the Democrats.

Since the Democrats fell to Trumpism ’24, they have developed a significant number of young, aggressive, and attractive candidates. Republicans now have two years to do the same, to move beyond the Trump generation of graft and thuggery and put forth candidates and a philosophy that separates the new generation from the old—although we don’t know if that can be done until their old and polarizing figure at the top is gone. The rebuilding will be retarded as long as the party continues to show him deference that he does not deserve.

We have seen several times when devastating losses have left some observers wondering if a political party is mortally wounded.

The answer is political parties are not mortally wounded.  They’re beaten and bruised but when they get off the mat, they have a new generation of candidates who will stand on their own and apart from the generation that had known only wrong roads to go down.

If the party sees 2026 as a learning experience, new faces, new attitudes, new messages will bubble up as it has happened among Democrats in these last two years. Democrats are well past the Biden generation.  It’s difficult to forecast if Republicans can shake off the dirt of the Trump era within the next two years but they certainly should have put it well behind by the next mid-terms.

We’ve heard some speculation that Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz are the early rallying figures for GOP loyalists.  Perhaps today.  But they are among the hole-diggers. By this time next year, we could see the post-Trump generation begin to emerge and begin to build its own identity and build its own challenges.

That new generation, however, will have to find a way to begin coming out from under the Trump shadow.  There will come a time when the new Republicans will have to show little care for what he might say about them or anything else.

Former Vice President Mike Pence emphasized that point in a recent interview with FOX News if the results of the elections encourage him to launch a presidential bid in ’28: “The most important thing is that we win the presidency…and to do that, I think it will be essential that we focus first on WHAT we’re for before we focus on WHO we’re for.  If we don’t return the Republican Party to the principles of a strong defense, limited government, fiscal responsibility, and the right to life, it won’t matter who we nominate in 2028 because this version of Republicanism was just rejected by the people.”

Those next generation Republicans Pence envisions will shape, or start to shape, the party’s Trumpless identity.  By 2030 the new generation will have matured and the nation will have largely or at least somewhat recovered politically from the damage done to the party, the country, and the international community by Trump.

Will we be back to a pure form of political adversarial relations?  There is no such thing as purity in politics. But maybe those competitors of the future will not leave us going to bed angry or scared every night.

The Democrats have a two-year head start of their turnaround. The Republican turnaround already has begun but it will be retarded by the baggage it will continue to carry for a while. Impeachment could speed up the process if enough Republicans line up with Democrats to create a new Republican era.

If we’re lucky, 2024, 2026, and 2028 will by 2030 be only a dark cloud in the rear view mirror.

At least, we can hope so.

The Twilight Of Donald Trump

As usual, Donald Trump blames everything and everyone except himself for the blue wave—some have called it a tsunami, a “bluenami,” someone has said, giving us a new political word that will become tiresome on second use. Regardless, it overwhelmed Republicans all the way down from Congress to legislatures and maybe to some county elections.

Trump claims the wave would not have materialized if he had been on the ballot. It seems, however, that this election indicates a majority of politicians and citizens strongly disagree with him. It’s interesting to see the number of high-ranking GOPers who now are citing Trump’s policies and actions with which they never previously disagreed as reasons for voter repudiation.

Trump told FOX News he will accept the results but not the blame. In one interview he said, “I don’t like to consider it a defeat for me; I wasn’t on the ballot. No matter how good the president is, you lose.”

As usual, he did two things. He lied and he avoided taking any responsibility for failure.   He, his policies, and his personality WERE on the ballot.  In fact, during some of his campaign “admire me, forget the candidate” speeches he urged the crowd to imagine he WAS on the ballot.  He will never admit it publicly and we wonder if he is capable of admitting in privately that he IS largely responsible for his party’s political disaster last Tuesday.

But his party cannot make a case that Trump alone is its scapegoat.  The Republican Party’s loyalty to him ultimately led to its ballot box disaster.  They gave him the ship of state and watched quietly as he ran it hard aground.

Various news agencies are reporting that Republicans finally realize their silent acquiescence to his demand for redistricting to protect his congressional majority was a mistake.  But loyal party members cannot ignore that they lacked the courage to tell him “no.”  That and the war and its impact on energy prices which tend to be felt at the gas pump and the grocery store alike and in the diesel prices for farmers and truckers, his nonsensical tariffs, his self-serving schemes became part of the many albatrosses around GOP necks far down the ballot.

Vice-President Vance tiptoed around the issue in a lengthy social media post:

“The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night,” Vance said. Trump also expressed no regrets and said he’d do it again, given the circumstances that he claims exist.  And Vance, ever loyal, left a couple of words out of his explanation.  What he could have said was “The reason we lost is President Trump’s war….”  But he couldn’t bring himself to go that far.

Trump’s colossal ego was on full display at every campaign stop in the last month before the election. The rallies were never about promoting the candidate or candidates. He babbled more about himself and made tasteless non-jokes that he thought showed him to be a charming fellow.  Frankly, we’re surprised more Republican candidates didn’t ask him to stay away.

He says he’ll work with the big Democrat majorities, claiming he has “lots of friends that are Democrats…I’ve already spoken to some of them.” He has not told us who are the ones he claims to have spoken to and as we write his, no Democrat has mentioned receiving any calls.

His now former chief of staff said Trump will keep being Trump, advocating cutting taxes and kicking out aliens.  He has indicated that he’ll rule with vetoes and executive orders.

His appointment of Stephen Miller as his new chief of staff sustains that opinion.

Democrats are in their strongest position ever when it comes to impeaching him a third time and the possibility of removal seems brighter because there’s no reason for Republicans to protect him.  Democrats also have the power to block appointments to fill key vacancies. One of the vacancies might be Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, who is contemplating retirement. He’s 76.

If Alito takes that course, it might be best if he does it now.  Trump is going to need all the time he can get to argue for confirmation of Alito’s successor. Hoping the Senate Democrats will let Alito’s successor sail through confirmation are woefully misplaced.

An important question, though, is whether impeaching Trump a third time should be the Democrats’ highest priority. While that lengthy and contentious process goes on, Trump can be doing a great deal more damage.

It will be interesting to see how Republicans try to wash the Trump tar from their hands in the next two years.  Will he be invited to their national convention in ’28?  Probably.  It would be a mistake to let him speak after 10 a.m., though.

Here in grassroots country, we will see how far down the list of state and local government offices Trump’s negatives continue to be felt in 2028.  Voters might remember those who did Trump’s bidding and aside from that, tried to make outlandish changes to the Missouri Constitution.  How the Republicans, with their shrunken majorities in both the Missouri House and the Missouri Senate behave in the next two years could determine whether the majorities shift.

Donald Trump has displayed long coattails that benefitted his party.  Now we wait to see if his party will be comfortable in his coattails for the next two years both in Washington and in Jefferson City.

Start/Stop the Steel 

President Trump’s steel tariffs are supposed to spur a steel industry renaissance in the United States.  He has bragged about the nation’s biggest-ever steel plant that will be built in Iowa but it doesn’t appear his tariffs have meant anything to a 120-year old steel company a day’s drive away in Wisconsin. Or the 25-year old steel plant across the river from St. Louis.

Earlier this year, Alton Steel announced it was closing, the company has announcing it’s going to sell its 381-acre plant site to a developer—–

—that is going to build a 200-megawatt data center there. And that’s just a start. TerraWatt is talking about building five data centers there that will add up to a one-gigawatt operations.

One might think such a project would generate a ton of jobs.  Nope. TerraWatt says fifty people could produce only FIFTY fulltime jobs.

Then there’s Trump’s big plans for Iowa and no plans for Wisconsin.  We’re not sure the creating of the big steel plant makes up for the problems Iowa farmers who voted for him two years ago are facing thanks to his various ill-considered policies.

Is he just spreading more bovine by product around to keep his Republican congressional majority?  For somebody who has no concept of agriculture, he is one of the world’s great byproduct spreaders. Maybe THE best.

Will the new steel plant provide jobs for workers who will get his $5,000 checks for voting for the GOP tomorrow.?

While he was Trumpeting great things for Iowa, reporters were telling about some folks in neighboring Wisconsin who were hearing Taps for their jobs in the steel industry.

The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel says Maynard Steel is shutting down after twelve decades in Milwaukee.  Sales dropped by about one-third last year and the company is losing more money this year.  At one time it had 725 workers. The newspaper says the 77 remaining employees will lose their jobs and their health care benefits on December 4.  A court-appointed receiver will sell the company’s assets after that. The company cites “business and industry circumstances” as reasons for he closure.

Maybe Trump needs to go to Milwaukee where he can perform the same miracle he performed in Indianapolis ten years ago when he saved all those jobs at the Carrier Air Conditioning plant.  Except he didn’t. The deal actually saved only about one-third of the jobs. Not mentioned in the Trump/Pence bragging about the deal was the Carrier went on to close a Carrier plant in another Indiana City, costing 700 more workers their jobs.

A little more than a year later, Carrier reported it was moving more than 600 other jobs to a new factory in China. In the end, Carrier moved more jobs out of Indiana than it kept.

Maybe the workers in Milwaukee can find jobs at the planned $15 billion big beautiful steel plant Trump has proclaimed will be built in Iowa, “the largest steel plant ever built in the United States,” proclaimed our President. His Commerce Secretary, Howard Lutnick said there was no doubt the plant would be built.

But it won’t be built by an American company.

There also is doubt, at least for now, about when the plant will be built. Trump said the plant already was under construction. Iowa TV station KWQC did some digging after thae announcement and found no significant property transactions this year in Lee County, where President Trump says it will be. No permit applications had been submitted.  No detailed plans had been sent to county authorities. Definitely no plant is being built right now, Trump notwithstanding. Some property owners, however, say a real estate agent has been snooping around.

Maynard Steel employees will have to go a long time without paychecks and health insurance if they think they can move to Iowa and get steel industry jobs.

Some skeptics think the announcement was a campaign stunt.  Critics think the original plans were for the plant to be built in Minnesota where Mesabi Minerals is developing a big mine and mill operation in the Mesabi Iron Range up north. The project has been delayed, the company complaining the delay is because of 2017 dispute involving a rival who cites “anti-competitive conduct” and charges Mesabi with antitrust violations.

The Des Moines Register has reported Mesabi and its parent company, Essar Group, have a troubled financial history (www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2026/10/01/mesabi-metallics-company-iowa-steel-plant-trump/92036812007/) in this country and in Canada.

Reporter Tyler Jeff has written, “In India, Business Today reported a few years ago that the Essar Group was one of the country’s most indebted companies and “notorious” for defaults dating back to 1999, when Essar Steel failed to pay $250 million to international creditors. In addition to the bankruptcies at the company’s U.S. and Canadian subsidiaries, the Essar Group restructured debt in Canada three times.”

He says the company has sold billions of dollars in assets and now has a big loan from a Russian state-owned financial institution behind its plans to mine taconite in northwest Minnesota and then transport it about 500 miles to Iowa’s southernmost county (Keokuk and Fort Madison area) for processing.

Once more, Trump seems to be doing something nice for somebody in Russia.

Trump’s announcement caused great excitement in Iowa, naturally.  It came at such a convenient time, too. One of Iowa’s seats in the U. S. Senate is very much in play this year with a Democratic challenger threatening to flip the seat now occupied by Joni Ernst, who is not seeking a third term.  The most recent poll shows Democrat Josh Turek, a state representative, and Congresswoman Ashley Hinson are close in a state Trump carried by 13 points two years ago. The Suffolk University poll says one-fourth of the voters Hinson has lost say her support of Trump is the reason.

So is Trump’s grand announcement just an effort to hold on to the traditionally red state of Iowa?   Or is it the real thing?  A Russian-financed Indian company with a rugged background is going to put $15 billion dollars into a steel plant about 500 miles from the place where the ore is mined.

The steel industry is changing but Trump’s campaign promise to return the industry to the United States certainly have an odd twist to it.

A Russian-financed company from India and the acquisition of U. S. Steel by Nippon Steel of Japan seem to be an odd way to go about  Making America Great Again in terms of the steel industry.

Will this deal turn out to be what Trump says it will be?  Or is it just another Carrier case?

He seems to be big on India and Japanese ownerships in the steel industry and doing favors for Russians. But for a 120-year old company in Milwaukee?   Where is he for those folks?

Maybe they don’t count because Minnesota is a blue state. And soon to be out of work steel company workers in Wisconsin and already out of work and already-unemployed steel workers in the St. Louis aren’t worth any attention when he’s desperately trying to keep Congress red.

-0-

 

Sunshine Patriots and Summer Soldiers

There is only one way the average citizen can stand up to Donald Trump and his increasingly repressive acts:

Vote against any candidate who either supports his administration or who lacks the courage to speak against it.

We will lose some good Republican office holders in November not because they are incompetent but because they are silent.  As Thomas Paine wrote in Common Sense in 1776:

Voters should evaluate their candidates with much greater thought and care this time, more than any time we have experienced. They and the state and the nation will be well-served by allowing their inner Independent to emerge and evaluate each candidate on both sides of the ballot with thought and concern.

We do not advocate wholesale rejection of the Republicans.  A Democrat might have less to offer to voters and should not be elected solely because that candidate has a D above their column. Likewise, individual Republicans should not be solely evaluated because of voter hostility toward the President. Think. Evaluate.

At the same time, this is no time to be a summer soldier and a sunshine patriot.  There must be a strong message from the citizens of this country that blind loyalty to Donald Trump carries a cost.

We have lived through the completely unnecessary election disaster that his demand for another Republican congressional district has caused with the Secretary of State turning himself into a pretzel trying to defend his actions and his party’s decisions supporting Trump’s wishes.

If I was a Republican candidate for the General Assembly, whether as a new person running for a House seat or a House member hoping move up to the Senate, I would look at the overwhelming rejection of two GOP amendments in August, the dropping survey figures for the President and for our Governor, the furor over congressional districts, and sense that approval of Republican proposals on the November ballot might not go well and I would carefully consider what kind of lawmaker I will promise to be—

—and then hope I get a chance to keep that promise, knowing that in just two years as a State Representative I will have a record no matter what I say I am for in this election.

This is a time for candidates on both sides of the aisle to honestly evaluate who they are. It is not enough for a Democrat to run on the concept that he or she is not a Republican.  It is not enough for a Republican to remain silent about current times and issues or to deny what they have done to contribute to them.

This is a time to start over for some, perhaps many, of our lawmakers to convincingly promise not to be who they have been and for others to be specific about what they want to do that will be better than what has been done.

It is not true that in politics a leopard cannot change his spots. Whether that leopard can be convincing in trying to do so is for voters to decide.

It is American to vote back and forth on the ballot.  We are living the danger of determining fitness of office only on the basis of an R or a D.  Do not be afraid to cross party lines. Your vote is secret. Only you will know. Voters must exercise their conscience when their party’s candidate will not exercise his.

Whether voters realize it or not, the future of our state is very much in their hands in November.

We voters should keep in mind the words of Lincoln in his address to a joint session of Congress in 1862:

“We of this Congress and this administration will be remembered in spite of ourselves. No personal significance, or insignificance, can spare one or another of us.”  What was good  advice for Congress at the start of the Civil War is good advice for the electorate today. These are dangerous, historic, times and we must remember, as Lincoln also said 164 years ago, “We cannot escape history.”

For generations we have failed to recognize the value of what we have obtained too cheaply and esteemed too lightly.

A President who has no loyalty to this nation and its people but only to himself is an albatross around the necks of many candidates who have not or will not stand apart from him and in their silence sanction the evil that he is and that he does.

Our preachers tells us it is never to late to repent and it is never too late to respect the truly penitent. That’s a good point to think about in the voting booth.

History will measure us severely by the choices we make in November.

(Image credit: libquotes.com)

What’s Left After Contempt and Concession 

Records in the State Supreme Court Historical Society indicate Secretary of State Denny Hoskins’ contempt of court case is the first contempt case before the court since 1878 and might be only the fifteenth in state history, none of which involved a statewide office holder.  All of the old cases were appeals of lower court contempt holdings. This could be the first time someone was held in contempt of the Missouri Supreme Court itself.

In my sixty years of reporting in Jefferson City, this is the first contempt of the Supreme Court case that I have ever seen.

Shortly before the court was to return with its finding Thursday afternoon, Hoskins buckled to the inevitable and notified local election officials that the congressional district map approved by the legislature in 2022 would be used in the November election.

His earlier notice said that the Republican gerrymandered districts adopted to please President Trump would be used—although other court rulings had blocked that usage.

The tricky issue of deciding a proper penalty for violating the court’s earlier order forbidding use of the gerrymandered districts was thus avoided.  Chief Justice W. Brent Powell noted that Hoskins could purge himself of his previous statement and orders and that he had done so with his letter to election authorities. The contempt ruling stands but there will be no punishment from the court. Whether feelings of voters when Hoskins is up for re-election in two years will take their due is something we’ll have to wait for.

There might be many bottom lines from this series of actions.  Legislative Republicans are 0-for-3 on major public policy decisions this year with two really hot issues on the ballot in November—

Amendment 3 prohibits abortion in most cases, and blocks gender transition procedures for people younger than 18. The amendment would overturn a more pro-choice amendment adopted by voters in 2024 after a petition campaign generated enough signatures for a ballot position. It got about 52% of the vote.

Amendment 6 says the legislature cannot change a law proposed by a petition and approved by voters without 80% percent of the voters agreeing with the change.

The other proposition is the one that upholds the gerrymandered redistricting plan, proposition A. What all of this fuss and feathers has resolved is that voters still can approve the new districts by adopting proposition A, which will make the districts available in the 2028 elections but not useful in protecting President Trump from a House and/or Senate controlled by Democrats after November’s election.

Republicans could go 0 for 6 this year on ballot issues if the People Not Politicians movement maintains its momentum or, with these court rulings, picks up strength.

There still remains one piece of absurdity in this ugly worship of The Donald.

A few hours before the court’s hearing and its ultimate ruling on contempt, fourteen members of the legislature threatened the court with impeachment.

The seven judges didn’t even blink when hearing of this threat.  They not only went ahead with the hearing and found Hoskins in contempt.

So now what?

The only thing goofier than the threat would be for these fourteen Republicans (and their colleagues) to file articles of impeachment in this week’s veto session. The court’s lack of interest in their threat gives them a choice: Look foolish for filing the threat or look foolish for going ahead with it.

How would they go about impeaching and convicting the court—all seven members?

Guess who conducts the trial of an impeached state official?   The Supreme Court, that’s who.  Impeaching one at a time leaves the other six to run a trial of a colleague, a pretty goofy idea. Maybe they could import the supreme court of a surrounding state to do it.

Goofiness seems to be the order of the day.

Will their threats generate votes for them and their party in November?  It’s hard to see that it will because of national surveys showing that President Trump’s behavior as a political bully isn’t going over anymore and in fact is turning people off, way off. .

What we have here, folks, seems to be that too many Republicans are lowering the anchor of the ship of state, not realizing the chain is wrapped around their own ankles.

The Republicans have handed Democrats wheelbarrows full of campaign issues that the D’s can use in the next two months or so to pound on R’s.

And in two more years, when the Governor, Attorney General (who represented Hoskins), and Hoskins come up for re-election along with legislative Republicans seeking re-election or election to a higher office, the Democrats still will be well-armed.

Republicans need to do some serious image repair. They need to pick up a major issue (or many major issues) that will sympathetically resonate with the people.

(Picture credit:  Front row (from left): Judge Fischer, Chief Justice Powell, Judge Ransom; Back row (from left): Judge Gooch, Judge Wilson, Judge Broniec, Judge Russell —Missouri Supreme Court;  Goofy—Etsy)

Chaos 

(Two important updates to this posting occurred overnight as the gigantic mess that will be our congressional elections in November has gotten even worse)  Look for  the boldface additions in this revised–for the third time—column).  

The two people in this household are going to vote in the November election. As of today, we are not sure who we will want to be our member of Congress because we aren’t sure which congressional district we will be in.

Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh might have settled it yesterday when he flatly rejected the appeal of the Missouri Supreme Court’s ruling that the old districts will be used for the election.  Kavanaugh is a Trump appointee and we would not be in this mess if Trump had not asked his loyal Republican-dominated legislature to skew congressional districts to help keep him in power.

However, shortly after that, a lower federal court judge ruled the other way.  We went to bed last night glad the day was over but knowing it is likely today will produce more political and judicial mayhem that none of us deserves but that all of us are getting, thanks to a President thinks our political system was invented just to keep him happy.

But since then, things have really heated up.

Shortly after that, the Chief Federal District Judge of this region, Stephen Clark, ruled the other way, issuing a temporary restraining order telling Hoskins to use the gerrymandered map while the case goes forward in the federal court system.  We went to bed last night glad the day was over but knowing it is likely today will produce more political and judicial mayhem that none of us deserves but that all of us are getting, thanks to a President thinks our political system was invented just to keep him happy. 

Governor Kehoe thanked the judge for providing “much needed clarity for Missouri voters and the election process.”  Since yesterday was the last day to make changes to the November ballot, he said, “the Missouri First Map will be used in the general election.”

He said, “Voters and candidates deserve consistency, certainty, and not to have the rules changed between elections,” an observation that is interesting because that is exactly what President Trump, the legislature, and Governor Kehoe have done “between elections” in 2024 and 2026. 

The scramble yesterday has left the Missouri Supreme Court, shall we say, in a state of high urinary agitation.  We awoke this morning to read a Missouri Independent report that the court has ordered Secretary of State Denny Hoskins to appear before it in person at 10 o’clock tomorrow morning to show why he should not be held in contempt of court for telling election officials to go ahead with a district map the court has forbidden him from using. It seems Hoskins had, as soon as Clark’s order came down, certified the official state ballot using the rejiggered congressional districts and sent the order, and his certification of the districts out to local election officials.  He says the Clark order, in effect, overrules the Missouri court’s order. 

The Chief Justice of the Missouri Supreme Court wants Hoskins to explain exactly why his actions “is not an affirmative violation” of the court’s injunction which has the backing of a United States Supreme Court judge (who ranks higher on the judicial food chain than Clark) and, “if he is not willing to comply with this court’s injunction, he should take no action in all things related to the congressional district map until guidance is received from a higher court…”

Chief Justice W. Brent Powell made it clear this hearing is a face-off between Hoskins and the court.  Nobody else will be allowed to intervene.  

The last time we can recall a sitting state official to answer to the Missouri Supreme Court was when the court tried and convicted Secretary of State Judy Moriarty in 1994 of committing impeachable offenses—-  

—–which raises a question about how all of this could eventually play out for Hoskins, should anyone want to make a case of it.  If the GOP continues to control the legislature, that question likely is going to be moot.

This whole ugly thing is compliments of the same political party that gave us two amendments that were stomped flat by voters in August, allowed a small number of maverick state senators to produce two or three of the least productive legislative sessions—probably since the Civil War when we had a government supported by the U. S. Army in Jefferson City and a bunch of exiles pretending to be a Confederate government based in Texas, and who so badly fumbled a chance to pass a sports gambling law that the interested parties gave us a constitutional amendment that is of grave disservice to the people of Missouri

Republicans have no one to blame but themselves if voter in November seek retribution for this craziness by promoting many GOP lawmakers back to private life. Will the majorities in the House and Senate switch in November? Probably not.  But we’ll be watching to see if the two-third majorities and the accompanying arrogance that comes with such margins disappears at the hands of voters who think these lawmakers have gone too far.

The Missouri Supreme court has blamed our Secretary of State, who was one of those maverick senators, for this mess.  And the court underlined its feelings with a unanimous vote.

The court suspended the congressional district maps drawn because President Trump is afraid he’ll lose control of Congress in November and asked the Missouri legislature to approve maps that will oust one of our senior congressmen, Emanuel Cleaver of Kansas City. That would giving the GOP one more Congressman from Missouri who can protect Trump..  The legislature was more than happy to oblige him.

But then some citizens who felt such manipulation of the political system more focused on government of one person, by one person, and for one person is not exactly what this country is all about.  They went around and collected signatures of about 300,000 other dissenters demanding the new map not go into effect until the people had agreed to it.  The number of signatures was more than adequate to put the question on the ballot.

Secretary of State Denny Hoskins apparently found some wiggle room in a federal district judge’s ruling last December that the new map would be suspended if the petition had enough signatures and a vote could be held on overturning that map. The judge’s opinion noted, however, that Hoskins believed he had the power to declare the petition itself was unconstitutional.

The Missouri Supreme Court told him, twice, that he had to rule on whether the petitions had enough signatures to put the issue on the ballot.

Rather than do that before the primary election that used the questionable new districts, Hoskins waited until the primary election was already underway before proclaiming the petition unconstitutional.

The Missouri Supreme Court said he screwed up, saying there actually are no new districts because opponents had gathered adequate signatures to have an election on their legitimacy. Unless voters approved the districts, they did not exist.

But Hoskins let the election proceed with the new districts.  So now we have candidates in our eight districts and—-

?

Justice Kavanaugh’s terse rejection of the districts is a second loud slap in the face of Hoskins and the obedient Trumpicans in our Capitol, coming after our Supreme Court’s ruling.

As we understand it these two rulings, we have no districts except the old ones and the candidates did not run in the old districts. They ran in the new ones which the court says don’t exist. The Missouri court has said rather clearly that Hoskins is responsible for any confusion the people of Missouri might have.

That’s a very heavy load of responsibility.  Hoskins will be up for re-election in 2028. Missourians are likely to be reminded of these events.

Out of this complicated embarrassment so far, however, is something vitally important. The Constitutional right of Missouri citizens “to petition the Government for a redress of grievances”     to enact laws through a petition process and to overturn offensive laws enacted by the people who are supposed to represent us has been upheld. The court decisions have upheld Missourians’ right to initiative and petition in overwhelming numbers. (Next year will be the 120th anniversary of the adoption of initiative and referendum in Missouri. We need to have a big celebration.)

Hoskins disputes the Missouri court’s ruling that he’s the one to blame.  He seemed to argue in a radio interview (KFTK) that the Trumpian map should be valid for November because voters used it in the primary election.

—although the State Supreme Court says they (we) voted in illegal and therefore nonexistent districts.  Justice Kavanaugh obviously didn’t buy Hoskins’ arguments either.

We must confess that we are as befuddled as most people are and we’re not convinced we understand all of this folderol or if we have explained the situation correctly.

If the districts were not legal, then there actually was no congressional primary election, right?   And those of us who voted were just rehearsing for the real thing. Can that be correct?  Are we headed to November with candidates nominated in a non-election?

And since the petition issue gathered enough signatures to merit a vote and no districts, old or new, will be established until voters have decided on the petition issue, how can we vote for our congressional delegation in November?

If it turns out that one of the winners in August is not a resident of the old district that might be in effect in November—-

Well?

I feel as if I am wading in the dark through an endless swamp of mashed potatoes and the legislature led me to it.  Lawmakers are back at the Capitol for a day or two next week to consider overriding any of the Governor’s vetoes from the spring session.  Can they, will they, do anything to restore some orderliness in our state political system?

To paraphrase an old saying:

“To err is human. To really screw up things you need a politician.”

I am now going to take some aspirin and lie down and hope this all passes.

(picture credit: Demotivators)

 

A Little Politics We’d Like to Forget 

Saturday nights when Liz and Rob were not taller than we are, Saturday nights had kind of a ritual to them.

At 5 p.m., I’d turn on KBIA, the National Public Radio Station at the University of Missouri, and wait for A Prairie Home Companion to come on.  I had my reel-to-reel SONY recorder wired into the radio and set at the slowest recording speed to record the two-hour program based around a mythical Minnesota town called Lake Wobegone (“a little town that time forgot and the decades cannot improve, where all of the women are strong, the men are good looking, and all the children are above average”) and the stories told by one of its former residents, Garrison Keillor.

I left the speakers off because we were still doing stuff at 5.  Dinner was usually about 6.  At 7 we’d gather in the living room where I rewound the tape and we’d listen back to the recording. Popcorn was part of the evening.  While the playback was underway, I’d turn on my cassette recorder and dub the program onto the smaller format.  There also in our house were some LP recordings of old radio programs—Jack Benny, Fibber and Molly, Suspense, Mr. Kean—Tracer of Lost Persons, Gangbusters, the Shadow, the Lone Ranger, the Green Hornet, Straight Arrow, Escape, etc.—some of which I dubbed onto cassettes before we went on long trips.

SiriusXm now has a channel for those old programs (the PHC is on Keillor’s webpage) but in those days, cars had cassette players and those programs came in handy when World War III broke out in the back seat.  I’d just slide a cassette of Garrison or Jack or Fibber or Molly or one of the creepy shows into the player and peace would immediately break out behind us.

The kids’ imaginations were immediately seized by those radio shows.  The “theatre of the mind” took over and for an hour or two the miles slipped by easily and quietly.

We are not alone in thinking children today are missing that important element in their development—-imagination.  Oh, they can imagine they are great dragon fighters or world-saving soldiers on their computers.  But it’s not the same, by far.

Radio could then, and still can today if we ignore the local stations that aren’t local anymore and aren’t imaginative anymore, and are mostly forums for people whose egos are their greatest asset, expand the mind far beyond anything we can see, even on a 100=inch flat screen screwed to the wall.

(In 1965, the great radio humorist Stan Freberg did a series of public service announcements for the Radio Advertising Bureau promoting radio.  They’re all priceless but the fourth one, “Stretching the Imagination” is considered the classic:

(bing.com/search?q=Stan+freberg+who+listens+to+radio&form=ANNTH1&refig=6a8601c200594754ba45e2583e91c5c7&pc=HCTS)

The Singer is Sarah Vaughan.

Garrison Keillor is no longer doing his radio program but he does do stage shows recreating the program. He’s 84 now, writes books, lives in New York instead of Minnesota, and writes with his familiar droll humor a daily column.

A few days ago on the 17th, he offered this observation that we decided to pass along:

(7) Another modest proposal, but a good one

Yes, It is obvious that he’s a Democrat. In fact one of his books is called Home Grown Democrat. But he seems to capture the contradictory, confusing, infuriating political mess we are living through.

Saturday nights at our house aren’t so interesting anymore. The kids are all grown up and have their own families.  Sometimes, though, we do have some popcorn.  And in our cars, we can listen to Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar, Gunsmoke (with William Conrad as Matt Dillon, Boston Blackie, Tales of the Texas Rangers, the creaking door of the Inner Sanctum and many more.

And the miles just slip away.

Just for the Record

There have been few times Missourians have so revolted against legislative proposals for new constitutional amendments as they did Tuesday.

Worst losses:

1912 Am 6  Authorizes land inheritance and utility taxes, excepts personal property, abolishes poll and occupational taxes, removes tax limits.  86,647-508,137    85.43% no

2026 Am 5  Phase out of Income Tax  233,309-1,165,085   83.31% no

1914  Am 14  Fifty million dollar bond issue  build and maintain state highways, authorizes a tax levy to pay off bonds (10 cents a gallon of gas)  76,542=378,530   83.17%  no

1918 Am 8  Restructures state tax system to derive public revenue form improved value of land 80,725-373,220   82.21% no

1914  Am 15 Allow petitions to authorize bond issue for road construction and maintenance. 80,935-373,202  82.18% no

2026 Am 4  Constitutional Amendments proposed by petition must be approved by votes in all congressional districts   275,040-1,122,748  80.32% no

1910 Am 8  Increase per diem for legislators  95,045-385,765    80.23% no

1914  Am 4  Establishes annual salary of $1,000 for member of legislature  89,629-355,326  79.85% no (rounded up to 80%)

November is a whole lot more interesting now—-and one question will be whether the Republicans can retain their two-thirds membership in the House and in the Senate.

And then there is 2028.——The offices of Governor, Lt. Governor, Secretary of Sate, Attorney General, and State Treasurer—all are held by Republicans—and all are up for decisions by voters.

 

Massive Repudiation

(This post has been updated to correct an error.  Amendment five failed in every county, not in all but one. We relied on erroneous information for the original post.)

It was not just a historic election—

It was an epic defeat for two constitutional amendments proposed by a legislature that is two-thirds Republican.

Missouri voters rejected amendments four and five by rates unseen in more than a century. The results for the income tax elimination amendment failed in every county and according to the New York Times just before midnight last night failed in one county, Shannon, 92-8 percent and failed in Maries County 90-10.

Here’s a simple explanation for the failure of Amendment 5—the income tax destruction amendment—and some observations about a flawed state fiscal policy:

The people who can’t afford more sales taxes defeated the people who don’t want to pay income taxes.

For folks to whom an income tax cut would be of relatively minor value while increased sales taxes would be a major blow, the defeat of the effort to excuse those to whom sales taxes are a minor thing from paying income taxes is a major victory, a crushing rejection of the legislature’s proposals.

We hope our lawmakers and/or the candidates to become lawmakers understand a sorry message:

The people at large do not trust them, at least not in matters of tax policy.

How will it play out in candidate elections in November? Incumbent Republicans might face intense demands to explain why they supported both of these amendment, especially Amendment 5.

Here’s a different approach that supporters of Amendment 5 might think about next:

Eliminate the sales tax.  Restructure the income tax so it spreads the fiscal responsibility for state finances more equitably across income levels but gives the folks on the margins some breathing room.

Governor Kehoe said one reason Amendment 5 was justified was because, “We don’t have a revenue problem. We have a spending problem.”

No.

We have both. And we’ve had them for a long time. And the thinking of the legislative majority has been for two decades that the state needs to lower its capabilities to raise money for programs and services for the people who put them in power.

Our spending problem will only increase by reducing our revenues. It would be the equivalent of solving a breathing problem through strangulation.  Fortunately, Missourians didn’t buy that irresponsible cure.

Our politics are filled with cliches, two of which are:

Government needs to be operated like a business.

You can’t cut your way to prosperity.

The Managing Editor of the Illinois Business Journal, Alan J. Ortbals observed in 2015:

Many people advocate government living within its means. Government needs to operate like a business, they say. Those who say that, however, apparently don’t know much about business…

Cost cutting alone creates a downward spiral — cuts diminish your product which reduces your sales which lead to more cuts that diminish your product and further reduce sales until you hang the “Going Out of Business” sign in the window.

Good government — like good business — requires stable revenue. Grover Norquist’s “No New Taxes” pledge is a mindless way to operate…Imagine running your business on a “No New Revenues” pledge. 

Ortbals called for a “balanced approach to government funding with a combination of revenue and cuts. You can’t do it all one way.”

He concluded, “Yes, government does need to operate like a business, which means working on both sides of the ledger to build a stable organization that can grow and prosper.”

Here is a question voters need to ask their candidates in November:  How are you going to build a stable state financial plan that encourages the state to grow and prosper?  What is your plan?

Jeremy Corbyn, a member of the House of Commons in England, put it most simply: “You grow your way to prosperity; you don’t cut your way to it.” It’s probably not an original statement because so many others have said it.

Shannon Power, a member of the Forbes Finance Council wrote in 2024, “The harsh reality is that you can’t cost-cut your way to sustainable growth.”

“The key to growth lies…in the strategic allocation of resources to areas that promise a return on investment. This requires a thorough analysis of where the company can generate growth. A go-to-market analysis of which industries are projected to grow in the coming years and/or which customers or potential customers are projected to increase spending next year is a good place to start.”

She was talking about business growth but in this case, running a government like a business has some applicability:

“The temptation to resort to short-term cost-cutting measures during uncertain times is commonplace. However, companies must recognize that sustainable growth requires strategic investments in areas that drive revenue…The key lies not in cutting costs—but in investing wisely for a prosperous future.”

Gut-touching political slogans won’t do the job. Simplistic steps that do not lift both ends of the boat are not steps toward greatness.  Only by broadening our views, and recognizing that growth begats growth can we lift Missouri from being a state ranked in the 30s and 40s to one other states can point to.

Let us hope that someday the kind of leadership emerges that makes us want to be such a state